Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Entity Framework - Affect of MultipleActiveResultSets on Caching

So I have a Class that looks something like the following. There is a thread that does some work using an Entity Framework Code First DbContext.

The problem I'm having is that it seems like m_DB context is caching data even though it should be disposed and recreated for every processing loop.

What I've seen is that some data in a relationship isn't present in the models loaded. If I kill and restart the process suddenly the data is found just like it should.

The only thing I can think of is this app is using the MultipleActiveResultSets=true in the database connection string, but I can't find anything stating clearly that this would cause the behavior I'm seeing.

Any insight would be appreciated.


public class ProcessingService
{

  private MyContext m_DB = null
  private bool m_Run = true;

  private void ThreadLoop()
  {
    while(m_Run)
    {
      try
      {
        if(m_DB == null)
          m_DB = new MyContext();
      }
      catch(Exception ex)
      {
        //Log Error
      }
      finally
      {
        if(m_DB != null)
        {
          m_DB.Dispose();
          m_DB = null;
        }
      }
    }
  }

  private void ProcessingStepOne()
  {
    // Do some work with m_DB
  }

  private void ProcessingStepTwo()
  {
    // Do some work with m_DB
  }
}

like image 518
raytiley Avatar asked Oct 24 '13 23:10

raytiley


People also ask

Should I use Multipleactiveresultsets?

You should enable MARS if you perform operations that require MARS, otherwise those will fail. Whether you or anyone else should write code that uses such operations is subjective.

Does Entity Framework cache data?

Entity Framework has the following forms of caching built-in: Object caching – the ObjectStateManager built into an ObjectContext instance keeps track in memory of the objects that have been retrieved using that instance. This is also known as first-level cache.

How does Entity Framework affect the connection with the database?

Because an open connection to the database consumes a valuable resource, the Entity Framework opens and closes the database connection only as needed. You can also explicitly open the connection. For more information, see Managing Connections and Transactions. Once in each application domain.

What does multiple active result sets do?

Multiple Active Result Sets (MARS) is a feature that allows the execution of multiple batches on a single connection. In previous versions, only one batch could be executed at a time against a single connection. Executing multiple batches with MARS does not imply simultaneous execution of operations.


2 Answers

Multiple Active Result Sets or MARS is a feature of SQL 2005/2008 and ADO.NET where one connection can be used by multiple active result sets (Just as the name implies). try switching this off on the connection string and observe the behaviour of the app, i am guessing that this could be the likely cause of your problem. read the following MSDN link for more on MARS

MSDN - Multiple Active Result Sets

Edit: Try:

var results = context.SomeEntitiy.AsNoTracking() where this = that select s;

AsNoTracking() switches off internal change tracking of entities and it should also force Entity Framework to reload entities every time.

Whatever said and done you will require some amount of re-factoring since there's obviously a design flaw in your code.

like image 150
Ahsan Avatar answered Nov 09 '22 01:11

Ahsan


I hate answering my own question, especially when I don't have a good explanation of why it fixes the problem.

I ended up removing MARS and it did resolve my issue. The best explanation I have is this:

Always read to the end of results for procedural requests regardless of whether they return results or not, and for batches that return multiple results. (http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms131686.aspx)

My application doesn't always read through all the results returned, so its my theory that this some how caused data to get cached and reused the new DbContext.

like image 20
raytiley Avatar answered Nov 09 '22 02:11

raytiley