Difference between extern int a; extern int a=42;

Question

While I was reading the answers of Use of 'extern' keyword while defining the variable

One of the user answered these way

 extern int a;       //  not a definition 
 extern int a = 42;  //  definition 

I was expecting both are not definitions but declarations. I was thinking Both statements says that the variable is defined outside the function and we have to use extern keyword to use it. is this a mistake by him or is it really a definition ? I know that

extern int a; // variable is already defined but its outside the function
extern int a=42 ; //I guess a variable is assigned a value but not a definition 

but these statement

extern int a = 42; // user said its a definition and now i got  confused

Please clear me with these.

Answer 1

Whenever initialisation is attempted, the statement becomes a definition, no matter that extern is used. The extern keyword is redundant in such a case because, by default, symbols not marked static already have external linkage.

It doesn't make sense to declare an external variable and set its initial value in the current compilation unit, that's a contradiction.