Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Create a random permutation of 1..N in constant space

Tags:

I am looking to enumerate a random permutation of the numbers 1..N in fixed space. This means that I cannot store all numbers in a list. The reason for that is that N can be very large, more than available memory. I still want to be able to walk through such a permutation of numbers one at a time, visiting each number exactly once.

I know this can be done for certain N: Many random number generators cycle through their whole state space randomly, but entirely. A good random number generator with state size of 32 bit will emit a permutation of the numbers 0..(2^32)-1. Every number exactly once.

I want to get to pick N to be any number at all and not be constrained to powers of 2 for example. Is there an algorithm for this?

like image 327
usr Avatar asked Apr 07 '12 13:04

usr


People also ask

How do you generate a random number from 1 to n?

Approach: Create an array of N elements and initialize the elements as 1, 2, 3, 4, …, N then shuffle the array elements using Fisher-Yates shuffle Algorithm. Fisher–Yates shuffle Algorithm works in O(n) time complexity. The assumption here is, we are given a function rand() that generates a random number in O(1) time.

How do you generate random permutations?

A simple algorithm to generate a permutation of n items uniformly at random without retries, known as the Fisher–Yates shuffle, is to start with any permutation (for example, the identity permutation), and then go through the positions 0 through n − 2 (we use a convention where the first element has index 0, and the ...

How do you generate random permutations in Python?

To generate random Permutation in Python, then you can use the np random permutation. If the provided parameter is a multi-dimensional array, it is only shuffled along with its first index. If the parameter is an integer, randomly permute np.

What is a random uniform permutation?

Page 1. Producing a Uniform Random Permutation. Def: A uniform random permutation is one in which each of the n! possible permutations are equally likely.


1 Answers

The easiest way is probably to just create a full-range PRNG for a larger range than you care about, and when it generates a number larger than you want, just throw it away and get the next one.

Another possibility that's pretty much a variation of the same would be to use a linear feedback shift register (LFSR) to generate the numbers in the first place. This has a couple of advantages: first of all, an LFSR is probably a bit faster than most PRNGs. Second, it is (I believe) a bit easier to engineer an LFSR that produces numbers close to the range you want, and still be sure it cycles through the numbers in its range in (pseudo)random order, without any repetitions.

Without spending a lot of time on the details, the math behind LFSRs has been studied quite thoroughly. Producing one that runs through all the numbers in its range without repetition simply requires choosing a set of "taps" that correspond to an irreducible polynomial. If you don't want to search for that yourself, it's pretty easy to find tables of known ones for almost any reasonable size (e.g., doing a quick look, the wikipedia article lists them for size up to 19 bits).

If memory serves, there's at least one irreducible polynomial of ever possible bit size. That translates to the fact that in the worst case you can create a generator that has roughly twice the range you need, so on average you're throwing away (roughly) every other number you generate. Given the speed an LFSR, I'd guess you can do that and still maintain quite acceptable speed.

like image 95
Jerry Coffin Avatar answered Sep 20 '22 13:09

Jerry Coffin