condition variable - why calling pthread_cond_signal() before calling pthread_cond_wait() is a logical error?

Question

It's written in POSIX threads tutorial https://computing.llnl.gov/tutorials/pthreads/ that it is a logical error.

my question is why it is a logical error?

In my program i need to use these signals, however i cannot guarantee that there will be a thread that will be in _cond_wait state. I tried to test it and nothing happens. Is this can cause unexpected behavior or worse?

thank you!

Answer 1

The answer of blaze comes closest, but is not totally clear:
conditional variables should only be used to signal a change in a condition.

Thread 1 checks a condition. If the condition doesn't meet, he waits on the condition variable until the condition meets. Because the condition is checked first, he shouldn't care whether the condition variable was signaled:

pthread_mutex_lock(&mutex);  while (!condition)     pthread_cond_wait(&cond, &mutex);  pthread_mutex_unlock(&mutex); 

Thread 2 changes the condition and signals the change via the condition variable. He doesn't care whether threads are waiting or not:

pthread_mutex_lock(&mutex);  changeCondition();  pthread_mutex_unlock(&mutex);  pthread_cond_signal(&cond) 

The bottom line is: the communication is done via some condition. A condition variable only wakes up waiting threads so they can check the condition.

Examples for conditions:

• Queue is not empty, so an entry can be taken from the queue
• A boolean flag is set, so the thread wait s until the other thread signal it's okay to continue
• some bits in a bitset are set, so the waiting thread can handle the corresponding events

see also pthread example