I'm teaching an intro to programming course and we're using Java. I want to help the students learn how to translate a written class specification into a working program. I will provide the written specification. It specifies the name of the class and behavior in the form of method signatures. I want the students to translate that into a working Java class.
I could provide them an interface and have them implement the interface, but that defeats part of the purpose: to read and interpret a written functional specification document. I want them to write the class from scratch. Then I want to grade their work.
My idea for checking their work is this: compile their Java class file against my own interface. If it compiles, then at least I'll know they've followed all the method contracts and I can start testing the functionality. If it doesn't compile, I'll get an error message reporting which methods were not implemented correctly.
How can I force a Java class file to be compiled against an interface even if none was originally specified in the source code?
In other words, let's say I have the following two files:
public interface FooInterface
{
...
}
public class Foo
{
...
}
I want to compile Foo as if it implemented FooInterface explicitly. But I don't want to have to manually edit a bunch of source code files in order to do so. How can I do it?
To address questions about the value of using a written spec vs providing the interface, here's what a hypothetical specification document looks like:
Write a class called Foo with the following methods:
oldest : ages (int[]) -> int
Given an array of ages, return the highest one.anyAdults : ages (int[]) -> boolean
Given an array of ages, return whether any of them are 18 or older.
IMO, this has a great educational benefit. The student has to critically evaluate whether their program obeys the spec. If I provided the interface file, they could unplug their brain and simply have the compiler tell them whether or not they were following the spec. Using the compiler as a cognitive crutch is the same technique the poorer students currently (unsuccessfully) employ to balance their braces and parentheses.
You could maybe do something like:
public class Bar extends Foo implements FooInterface{}
If FooInterface is fully satisfied by Foo then Bar will not have any errors.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With