Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Compare two structs' values in C#

I'm not looking for a comparison of two structs that returns bool, I am wondering if there is a way to get which fields of two structs (the same structure, but maybe different values) are different. Basically I want a simpler way to do the following:

public class Diff
{
    public String VarName;
    public object Val1;
    public object Val2;

    public Diff(String varName, object val1, object val2)
    {
        VarName = varName;
        Val1 = val1;
        Val2 = val2;
    }

    public override string ToString()
    {
        return VarName + " differs with values " + Val1 + " and " + Val2;
    }
}

public struct TestStruct
{
    public int ValueOne;
    public int ValueTwo;
    public int ValueThree;

    public List Compare(TestStruct inTestStruct)
    {
        List diffs = new List();
        if (ValueOne != inTestStruct.ValueOne)
        {
            diffs.Add(new Diff("ValueOne", ValueOne, inTestStruct.ValueOne));
        }
        if (ValueTwo != inTestStruct.ValueTwo)
        {
            diffs.Add(new Diff("ValueTwo", ValueTwo, inTestStruct.ValueTwo));
        }
        if (ValueThree != inTestStruct.ValueThree)
        {
            diffs.Add(new Diff("ValueThree", ValueThree, inTestStruct.ValueThree));
        }
        return diffs;
    }
}

public CompareStructsExample()
{
    TestStruct t1 = new TestStruct();
    t1.ValueOne = 1;
    t1.ValueTwo = 8;
    t1.ValueThree = 5;

    TestStruct t2 = new TestStruct();
    t2.ValueOne = 3;
    t2.ValueTwo = 8;
    t2.ValueThree = 7;

    List diffs = t1.Compare(t2);
    foreach (Diff d in diffs)
    {
        System.Console.WriteLine(d.ToString());
    }
}

I'm wondering if there is a way to do this with serialization of some sort, or if this is the only way to actually see which values have changed. Even if there is a better way to implement the Compare function, I would take that too.

like image 948
SwDevMan81 Avatar asked Jun 11 '09 20:06

SwDevMan81


People also ask

Can you compare two structs in C?

To find out if they are the same object, compare pointers to the two structs for equality. If you want to find out in general if they have the same value you have to do a deep comparison. This involves comparing all the members. If the members are pointers to other structs you need to recurse into those structs too.

Can we equate two structures in C?

Yes, you can assign one instance of a struct to another using a simple assignment statement.

Why we Cannot compare structures in C?

We should not compare structures because of the holes between the member fields of a structure. Comparing the structures themselves as variables won`t work.

Can we compare two structures using any built in operator?

Yeah. It is relational operator. Relational operators are only used to compare two or more things.


2 Answers

It can be done using Reflection. Check for FieldInfo and PropertyInfo examples.

MSDN example (modified a bit):

    Type myType = typeof(TestStruct);

    // Get the fields of TestStruct.
    FieldInfo[] myFieldInfo = 
        myType.GetFields(
           BindingFlags.NonPublic | BindingFlags.Instance | BindingFlags.Public);

    Console.WriteLine("\nThe fields of TestStruct are \n");

    // Display the field information of TestStruct.
    for(int i = 0; i < myFieldInfo.Length; i++)
    {
        Console.WriteLine("\nName            : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].Name);
        Console.WriteLine("Declaring Type  : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].DeclaringType);
        Console.WriteLine("IsPublic        : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].IsPublic);
        Console.WriteLine("MemberType      : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].MemberType);
        Console.WriteLine("FieldType       : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].FieldType);
        Console.WriteLine("IsFamily        : {0}", myFieldInfo[i].IsFamily);
    }
like image 123
Groo Avatar answered Sep 17 '22 22:09

Groo


Linq?

  public List<string> Compare(TestStruct x, TestStruct y) {  
    return (  
      from l1 in x.GetType().GetFields()  
      join l2 in y.GetType().GetFields() on l1.Name equals l2.Name  
      where !l1.GetValue(x).Equals(l2.GetValue(y))  
      select string.Format("{0} {1} {2}", l1.Name, l1.GetValue(x), l2.GetValue(y))  
    ).ToList();  
  }  
like image 39
johnnycrash Avatar answered Sep 21 '22 22:09

johnnycrash