Compare these products for PDF generation with Java given requirements inside: iText, Apache PDFBox or FOP? [closed]

Question

There were questions on that but not recently and technology must have gone ahead since then.

Requirements:

• generating pdf documents based on predefined template (I can use either pdf forms or xsl-fo)
• being able to fill textual data
• being able to fill graphical data (generated bar codes)
• being able to alter pdf template in production environment without patching (recompiling)
• generating pdf file to be saved in the database (as blob) and/or printed
• open source/free

The options assumed are iText, PDFBox, FOP, anything else? What are recommendations based on the requirements above?

Answer 1

1. iText; nowadays iText is a commercial library, the latest version is not for free anymore (a fork of an older version remains under MIT license: OpenPDF)
2. FOP; I worked a lot with FOP. It's fairly resource intensive (Java > XML > XSLT > PDF) and complex PDFs become a nightmare ( may result in XSLTs with 20k+ LoC)
3. PDFBox; it seems to be the best alternative although I did not work with it in large projects
4. Did not check Flying Saucer yet

To conclude, I'd give PDFBox a try. Depending on your bar code requirements you may need to inline your barcode (font) into the PDF or distribute the font to your clients - take care of those issues.

Answer 2

I've done a project with Flying Saucer http://code.google.com/p/flying-saucer/ which is based on iText. It's free, easy to use, has great support for CSS, and has nice open source.