Can static methods that return a value throw an exception?

Question

I have a static method that returns a String, but in the event that the string that is passed in does not match one of several words, I want to throw an exception. The code below is just a sample of what I am trying to do, but I keep getting "non static variable this cannot be referenced from a static context" message on the line where I throw the exception. Basically, the return value from getMsg has to be valid, or the program cannot proceed, so I need a way to catch this.

public static String getMsg(String input) throws UnknownInputException{
      if (input.equals("A")){
           return "key for A";
      }
      throw new UnknownInputException("Some Message");
      return "unknownInput";

Answer 1

The problem is caused by the fact, that UnknownInputException is probably a nested class, and if you instantiate it with the new operator, as a nested class, it should have access to a "parent" object - which doesn't exist since the class was instantiated in a static context. For more information about this, see Static method returning inner class.

A possible solution would be to declare UnknownInputException as static like this:

private static class UnknownInputException extends Exception { ... }

Of course, you won't be able to access any instance (non-static) methods and/or fields from this class, but that might not be an issue in your case (especially in case of an Exception class).

Also, returning value after the throw line is unnecessary, as execution will never reach that line.

Answer 2

The variable this is not noted in the given example code, so it can not cause an error.

The code return "unknownInput"; is redundant since never executed.

There must be another static method in which this is used, that causes the error.