C# - closures over class fields inside an initializer?

Question

Consider the following code:

using System;

namespace ConsoleApplication2
{
    class Program
    {
        static void Main(string[] args)
        {
            var square = new Square(4);
            Console.WriteLine(square.Calculate());
        }
    }

    class MathOp
    {        
        protected MathOp(Func<int> calc) { _calc = calc; }
        public int Calculate() { return _calc(); }
        private Func<int> _calc;
    }

    class Square : MathOp
    {
        public Square(int operand)
            : base(() => _operand * _operand)  // runtime exception
        {
            _operand = operand;
        }

        private int _operand;
    }
}

(ignore the class design; I'm not actually writing a calculator! this code merely represents a minimal repro for a much bigger problem that took awhile to narrow down)

I would expect it to either:

• print "16", OR
• throw a compile time error if closing over a member field is not allowed in this scenario

Instead I get a nonsensical exception thrown at the indicated line. On the 3.0 CLR it's a NullReferenceException; on the Silverlight CLR it's the infamous Operation could destabilize the runtime.

Answer 1

It was a compiler bug that has been fixed. The code should never have been legal in the first place, and if we were going to allow it, we should have at least generated valid code. My bad. Sorry about the inconvenience.