buffered asynchronous file I/O on linux

Question

I am looking for the most efficient way to do asynchronous file I/O on linux.

The POSIX glibc implementation uses threads in userland.

The native aio kernel api only works with unbuffered operations, patches for the kernel to add support for buffered operations exist, but those are >3 years old and no one seems to care about integrating them into the mainline.

I found plenty of other ideas, concepts, patches that would allow asynchronous I/O, though most of them in articles that are also >3 years old. What of all this is really available in todays kernel? I've read about servlets, acalls, stuff with kernel threads and more things I don't even remember right now.

What is the most efficient way to do buffered asynchronous file input/output in todays kernel?

Answer 1

Unless you want to write your own IO thread pool, the glibc implementation is an acceptable solution. It actually works surprisingly well for something that runs entirely in userland.

The kernel implementation does not work with buffered IO at all in my experience (though I've seen other people say the opposite!). Which is fine if you want to read huge amounts of data via DMA, but of course it sucks big time if you plan to take advantage of the buffer cache.
Also note that the kernel AIO calls may actually block. There is a limited size command buffer, and large reads are broken up into several smaller ones. Once the queue is full, asynchronous commands run synchronously. Surprise. I've run into this problem a year or two ago and could not find an explanation. Asking around gave me the "yeah of course, that's how it works" answer.
From what I've understood, the "official" interest in supporting buffered aio is not terribly great either, despite several working solutions seem to be available for years. Some of the arguments that I've read were on the lines of "you don't want to use the buffers anyway" and "nobody needs that" and "most people don't even use epoll yet". So, well... meh.

Being able to get an epoll signalled by a completed async operation was another issue until recently, but in the meantime this works really fine via eventfd.

Note that the glibc implementation will actually spawn threads on demand inside __aio_enqueue_request. It is probably no big deal, since spawning threads is not that terribly expensive any more, but one should be aware of it. If your understanding of starting an asynchronous operation is "returns immediately", then that assumption may not be true, because it may be spawning some threads first.

EDIT:
As a sidenote, under Windows there exists a very similar situation to the one in the glibc AIO implementation where the "returns immediately" assumption of queuing an asynchronous operation is not true.
If all data that you wanted to read is in the buffer cache, Windows will decide that it will instead run the request synchronously, because it will finish immediately anyway. This is well-documented, and admittedly sounds great, too. Except in case there are a few megabytes to copy or in case another thread has page faults or does IO concurrently (thus competing for the lock) "immediately" can be a surprisingly long time -- I've seen "immediate" times of 2-5 milliseconds. Which is no problem in most situations, but for example under the constraint of a 16.66ms frame time, you probably don't want to risk blocking for 5ms at random times. Thus, the naive assumption of "can do async IO from my render thread no problem, because async doesn't block" is flawed.

Answer 2

The material seems old -- well, it is old -- because it's been around for long and, while by no means trivial, is well understood. A solution you can lift is published in W. Richard Stevens's superb and unparalleled book (read "bible"). The book is the rare treasure that is clear, concise, and complete: every page gives real and immediate value:

    Advanced Programming in the UNIX Environment

Two other such, also by Stevens, are the first two volumes of his Unix Network Programming collection:

   Volume 1: The Sockets Networking API (with Fenner and Rudoff) and
   Volume 2: Interprocess Communications

I can't imagine being without these three fundamental books; I'm dumbstruck when I find someone who hasn't heard of them.

Still more of Steven's books, just as precious:

   TCP/IP Illustrated, Vol. 1: The Protocols