Blobs with OpenCV. Which library is best? [closed]

Question

I plan to start experimenting with blobs as a C++ user, with some experience at cv::Mat's from the OpenCV.

Now the question is, which blobs library should I use if at all?

I have seen these alternatives so far:

1. cvBlobs (on google code) -- that is a c library really, working with IplImage so it needs serious adaptation to c++.
2. CvBlobsLib (on willowgarage opencv webpage) -- that looks like a c++ library but has quite bad docs with plenty of stuff left unexplained and barely any code example.
3. I have seen cv::findContours, cv::moments and cv::drawContours in the OpenCV 2.4.3 library.

What do you suggest as an expert? My pressing issue: what will the new OpenCV not cover of cvBlobs on google code?

---

Here is the link for the follow-up question on this subject, where I ask about SimpleBlobDetector. You might be interested.

Answer 1

You should use the SimpleBlobDetector class in OpenCV 2.4. You pretty much create an object of type SimpleBlobDetector and then call the detect(cv::Mat input, vector<cv::KeyPoint> keypoints, cv::Mat mask) function with a cv::Mat image as input, an empty vector for keypoints, and another cv::Mat as an optional mask for a specific area of the image to look for keypoints in.

Note that the cv::Mat object has taken over image and matrix storage duty for all of the formerly separate image and matrix classes in the earlier releases of OpenCV.

Answer 2

You should take a look at the new opencvblobslib. It has great features like multi core support.