Best way to allow plugins for a PHP application

Question

You could use an Observer pattern. A simple functional way to accomplish this:

<?php

/** Plugin system **/

$listeners = array();

/* Create an entry point for plugins */
function hook() {
    global $listeners;

    $num_args = func_num_args();
    $args = func_get_args();

    if($num_args < 2)
        trigger_error("Insufficient arguments", E_USER_ERROR);

    // Hook name should always be first argument
    $hook_name = array_shift($args);

    if(!isset($listeners[$hook_name]))
        return; // No plugins have registered this hook

    foreach($listeners[$hook_name] as $func) {
        $args = $func($args); 
    }
    return $args;
}

/* Attach a function to a hook */
function add_listener($hook, $function_name) {
    global $listeners;
    $listeners[$hook][] = $function_name;
}

/////////////////////////

/** Sample Plugin **/
add_listener('a_b', 'my_plugin_func1');
add_listener('str', 'my_plugin_func2');

function my_plugin_func1($args) {
    return array(4, 5);
}

function my_plugin_func2($args) {
    return str_replace('sample', 'CRAZY', $args[0]);
}

/////////////////////////

/** Sample Application **/

$a = 1;
$b = 2;

list($a, $b) = hook('a_b', $a, $b);

$str  = "This is my sample application\n";
$str .= "$a + $b = ".($a+$b)."\n";
$str .= "$a * $b = ".($a*$b)."\n";

$str = hook('str', $str);
echo $str;
?>

Output:

This is my CRAZY application
4 + 5 = 9
4 * 5 = 20

Notes:

For this example source code, you must declare all your plugins before the actual source code that you want to be extendable. I've included an example of how to handle single or multiple values being passed to the plugin. The hardest part of this is writing the actual documentation which lists what arguments get passed to each hook.

This is just one method of accomplishing a plugin system in PHP. There are better alternatives, I suggest you check out the WordPress Documentation for more information.

So let's say you don't want the Observer pattern because it requires that you change your class methods to handle the task of listening, and want something generic. And let's say you don't want to use extends inheritance because you may already be inheriting in your class from some other class. Wouldn't it be great to have a generic way to make any class pluggable without much effort? Here's how:

<?php

////////////////////
// PART 1
////////////////////

class Plugin {

    private $_RefObject;
    private $_Class = '';

    public function __construct(&$RefObject) {
        $this->_Class = get_class(&$RefObject);
        $this->_RefObject = $RefObject;
    }

    public function __set($sProperty,$mixed) {
        $sPlugin = $this->_Class . '_' . $sProperty . '_setEvent';
        if (is_callable($sPlugin)) {
            $mixed = call_user_func_array($sPlugin, $mixed);
        }   
        $this->_RefObject->$sProperty = $mixed;
    }

    public function __get($sProperty) {
        $asItems = (array) $this->_RefObject;
        $mixed = $asItems[$sProperty];
        $sPlugin = $this->_Class . '_' . $sProperty . '_getEvent';
        if (is_callable($sPlugin)) {
            $mixed = call_user_func_array($sPlugin, $mixed);
        }   
        return $mixed;
    }

    public function __call($sMethod,$mixed) {
        $sPlugin = $this->_Class . '_' .  $sMethod . '_beforeEvent';
        if (is_callable($sPlugin)) {
            $mixed = call_user_func_array($sPlugin, $mixed);
        }
        if ($mixed != 'BLOCK_EVENT') {
            call_user_func_array(array(&$this->_RefObject, $sMethod), $mixed);
            $sPlugin = $this->_Class . '_' . $sMethod . '_afterEvent';
            if (is_callable($sPlugin)) {
                call_user_func_array($sPlugin, $mixed);
            }       
        } 
    }

} //end class Plugin

class Pluggable extends Plugin {
} //end class Pluggable

////////////////////
// PART 2
////////////////////

class Dog {

    public $Name = '';

    public function bark(&$sHow) {
        echo "$sHow<br />\n";
    }

    public function sayName() {
        echo "<br />\nMy Name is: " . $this->Name . "<br />\n";
    }


} //end class Dog

$Dog = new Dog();

////////////////////
// PART 3
////////////////////

$PDog = new Pluggable($Dog);

function Dog_bark_beforeEvent(&$mixed) {
    $mixed = 'Woof'; // Override saying 'meow' with 'Woof'
    //$mixed = 'BLOCK_EVENT'; // if you want to block the event
    return $mixed;
}

function Dog_bark_afterEvent(&$mixed) {
    echo $mixed; // show the override
}

function Dog_Name_setEvent(&$mixed) {
    $mixed = 'Coco'; // override 'Fido' with 'Coco'
    return $mixed;
}

function Dog_Name_getEvent(&$mixed) {
    $mixed = 'Different'; // override 'Coco' with 'Different'
    return $mixed;
}

////////////////////
// PART 4
////////////////////

$PDog->Name = 'Fido';
$PDog->Bark('meow');
$PDog->SayName();
echo 'My New Name is: ' . $PDog->Name;

In Part 1, that's what you might include with a require_once() call at the top of your PHP script. It loads the classes to make something pluggable.

In Part 2, that's where we load a class. Note I didn't have to do anything special to the class, which is significantly different than the Observer pattern.

In Part 3, that's where we switch our class around into being "pluggable" (that is, supports plugins that let us override class methods and properties). So, for instance, if you have a web app, you might have a plugin registry, and you could activate plugins here. Notice also the Dog_bark_beforeEvent() function. If I set $mixed = 'BLOCK_EVENT' before the return statement, it will block the dog from barking and would also block the Dog_bark_afterEvent because there wouldn't be any event.

In Part 4, that's the normal operation code, but notice that what you might think would run does not run like that at all. For instance, the dog does not announce it's name as 'Fido', but 'Coco'. The dog does not say 'meow', but 'Woof'. And when you want to look at the dog's name afterwards, you find it is 'Different' instead of 'Coco'. All those overrides were provided in Part 3.

So how does this work? Well, let's rule out eval() (which everyone says is "evil") and rule out that it's not an Observer pattern. So, the way it works is the sneaky empty class called Pluggable, which does not contain the methods and properties used by the Dog class. Thus, since that occurs, the magic methods will engage for us. That's why in parts 3 and 4 we mess with the object derived from the Pluggable class, not the Dog class itself. Instead, we let the Plugin class do the "touching" on the Dog object for us. (If that's some kind of design pattern I don't know about -- please let me know.)

The hook and listener method is the most commonly used, but there are other things you can do. Depending on the size of your app, and who your going to allow see the code (is this going to be a FOSS script, or something in house) will influence greatly how you want to allow plugins.

kdeloach has a nice example, but his implementation and hook function is a little unsafe. I would ask for you to give more information of the nature of php app your writing, And how you see plugins fitting in.

+1 to kdeloach from me.

Here is an approach I've used, it's an attempt to copy from Qt signals/slots mechanism, a kind of Observer pattern. Objects can emit signals. Every signal has an ID in the system - it's composed by sender's id + object name Every signal can be binded to the receivers, which simply is a "callable" You use a bus class to pass the signals to anybody interested in receiving them When something happens, you "send" a signal. Below is and example implementation

    <?php

class SignalsHandler {


    /**
     * hash of senders/signals to slots
     *
     * @var array
     */
    private static $connections = array();


    /**
     * current sender
     *
     * @var class|object
     */
    private static $sender;


    /**
     * connects an object/signal with a slot
     *
     * @param class|object $sender
     * @param string $signal
     * @param callable $slot
     */
    public static function connect($sender, $signal, $slot) {
        if (is_object($sender)) {
            self::$connections[spl_object_hash($sender)][$signal][] = $slot;
        }
        else {
            self::$connections[md5($sender)][$signal][] = $slot;
        }
    }


    /**
     * sends a signal, so all connected slots are called
     *
     * @param class|object $sender
     * @param string $signal
     * @param array $params
     */
    public static function signal($sender, $signal, $params = array()) {
        self::$sender = $sender;
        if (is_object($sender)) {
            if ( ! isset(self::$connections[spl_object_hash($sender)][$signal])) {
                return;
            }
            foreach (self::$connections[spl_object_hash($sender)][$signal] as $slot) {
                call_user_func_array($slot, (array)$params);
            }

        }
        else {
            if ( ! isset(self::$connections[md5($sender)][$signal])) {
                return;
            }
            foreach (self::$connections[md5($sender)][$signal] as $slot) {
                call_user_func_array($slot, (array)$params);
            }
        }

        self::$sender = null;
    }


    /**
     * returns a current signal sender
     *
     * @return class|object
     */
    public static function sender() {
        return self::$sender;
    }

}   

class User {

    public function login() {
        /**
         * try to login
         */
        if ( ! $logged ) {
            SignalsHandler::signal(this, 'loginFailed', 'login failed - username not valid' );
        }
    }

}

class App {
    public static function onFailedLogin($message) {
        print $message;
    }
}


$user = new User();
SignalsHandler::connect($user, 'loginFailed', array($Log, 'writeLog'));
SignalsHandler::connect($user, 'loginFailed', array('App', 'onFailedLogin'));

$user->login();

?>