What in everyone's opinion is the best representation for a time-bound hierarchy in SQL?
What I mean by this is:
- On any given date you have a normal tree hierarchy
- This hierarchy can change from day to date
- Each child still only has one parent on any given date
Day 1...
Business
|
|-Joe
| |-Happy
| |-Sneezy
| |-Doc(*)
|
|-Moe
|-Bashfull
|-Sleepy
Day 2...
Business
|
|-Joe
| |-Happy
| |-Sneezy
|
|-Moe
|-Doc(*)
|-Bashfull
|-Sleepy
At any time, a child can join the hierarchy for the first time, or leave the hierarchy completely. (For example, new employees, and retired employees.)
The main considerations:
I know how I do it at present, but am intrigued as to how other people may do it :)
EDIT
I naively assumed a few considerations so will be more explicit...
The generic nature is most important (forming just one part of a generic relational mode), combined with ease of use for driving report (for any part of the tree across any range of dates) and the ability to be updated reliably.
A hierarchical database is a data model in which data is stored in the form of records and organized into a tree-like structure, or parent-child structure, in which one parent node can have many child nodes connected through links.
Use hierarchyid as a data type to create tables with a hierarchical structure, or to describe the hierarchical structure of data that is stored in another location. Use the hierarchyid functions in Transact-SQL to query and manage hierarchical data.
Examples of Hierarchical Database SystemsIBM's Information Management System (IMS) is an example of a hierarchical database system. Windows Registry is another such example. Another example that you may be aware of is XML data storage that we discussed earlier. XML has a root node enclosing one or more child nodes.
There are several different books of relevance here - one set is for 'temporal databases', and the other for 'hierarchical structures in RDBMS'.
The tricky parts of your question, it seems to me, are:
Viewing the whole hierarchy across a date range
Reporting on whole sub-trees across a date range
The other items are, if not straight-forward, then manageable using the techniques outlined in the books, and along the lines suggested in other answers. Part of the problem is understanding what those two bullet points mean. In one sense, they are 'the same'; the 'whole hierarchy' is just a special case of 'whole sub-trees'. But the deeper question is 'how do you want to demonstrate - visualize, represent - the changes in the hierarchy over time?' Are you seeking to compare the states at the start and end times, or are you seeking to see the intermediate changes too? How do you want to represent the moves of an individual within a hierarchy?
More questions than answers - but I hope the pointers are some help.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With