Avoiding 401 response for each request using NTLM

Question

We have here an asp.net 3.5 application using NTLM based windows authentication. The system runs on a private network that actually distributed over different geographic places (connected via VPN).

We are now trying to optimize the website's performance. Because the way NTLM works, every new request to the IIS is composed with 3 different requests while the first 2 is 401 responses. We are trying to minimize the amount of these requests to be only at the beginning of the session. We found this solution. Unfortunately it didn't change anything and we keep getting this 401 response (which consumes time).

In order to see the traffic i first used the Fiddler app. Somehow, when I use Fiddler, there is only 1 authentication process at the beginning of the session (exactly as I wish), but when I close Fiddler and check the traffic via WireShark I can see that I still have this 401 response for each request.

The used clients are IE6, IIS version 6.

Can someone advise?

Answer 1

NTLM/Negotiate, unlike all other HTTP authentication schemes, are connection-oriented protocols.

In IIS, there are various settings which control whether authentication will be demanded for all requests on a previously authenticated connection (e.g. AuthPersistSingleRequest). Independent of that setting, I believe IIS will automatically demand re-authentication when making a POST request.

If your server is impairing connection reuse (e.g. by sending a Connection: close header in responses) you must fix that because otherwise the reauthentication will occur. You can easily check for such authentication-reuse foiling headers using Fiddler.

Answer 2

The only way is to use NTLM on login page only and use cookie like here