Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Are there any real life uses for the Java _signed_ byte primitive type?

Tags:

java

types

byte

For some inexplicable reason the byte primitive type is signed in Java. This mean that valid values are -128..127 instead of the usual 0..255 range representing 8 significant bits in a byte (without a sign bit).

This mean that all byte manipulation code usually does integer calculations and end up masking out the last 8 bits.

I was wondering if there is any real life scenario where the Java byte primitive type fits perfectly or if it is simply a completely useless design decision?


EDIT: The sole actual use case was a single-byte placeholder for native code. In other words, not to be manipulated as a byte inside Java code.


EDIT: I have now seen a place where an inner tight loop needed to divide by 7 (numbers 0..32) so a lookup table could be done with bytes as the datatype so the memory usage could be kept low thinking of L1 cache usage. This does not refer to the signed/unsignedness but was a case of an actual usage.

like image 381
Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen Avatar asked Jul 31 '11 21:07

Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen


People also ask

What is the use of byte data type in Java?

byte: The byte data type is an 8-bit signed two's complement integer. It has a minimum value of -128 and a maximum value of 127 (inclusive). The byte data type can be useful for saving memory in large arrays, where the memory savings actually matters.

What are the example of byte in Java?

byte Syntax in JAVA: byte Variable_Name = Value; For example: byte x = 10; Here x is variable name and 10 is a value assigned to a variable integer data type byte.

Does Java have byte?

The byte data type in Java is a signed integer based on the two's complement 8-bit mechanism. It is different from the int data type that uses 4 bytes (i.e., 32-bit to store a number). The values that can be stored in a single byte are -128 to 127. byte data types are primitive.


1 Answers

Josh Bloch recently mentioned in a presentation that this is one of the mistakes in the language.

I think the reason behind this is that java does not have unsigned numeric types, and byte should conform to that rule. (Note: char is unsigned, but does not represent numbers)

As for the particular question: I can't think of any example. And even if there were examples, they would be fewer than the ones for 0..255, and they could be implemented using masking (rather than the majority)

like image 146
Bozho Avatar answered Oct 18 '22 16:10

Bozho