Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Are there any alternatives to OData? [closed]

OData is used by Netflix and in many of Microsoft's products (servers: CRM, Sharepoint, SQL Server; clients: Excel).

While OData is interesting, it has it's own set of benefits and trade-offs.

I've designed and build a custom search engine for internal use. Many developers are using the search engine for reporting and lists, replacing the reports and custom search/filter functionality in each line of business app with this search engine.

I have a decent system to allow querying/filtering in my search engine. It's all url driven so it's easy to use.

At this point, I want to add a little bit more functionality to the URL "command line". OData is a tempting choice because we use a lot of Microsoft tech already. It also has standard language for filters with Boolean logic, etc.

Are there any other legitimate standards based REST frameworks like OData that I should look at?

I'm not sure I need the full OData stack for what I'm doing. My simple query string based filtering is working very well at this point. Just want to conduct some due diligence so I can make an informed decision.

Thanks.

Edit

What I'm looking for is more of a framework for creating my search API. Lucene/Solr use a url syntax http://lucene.apache.org/solr/tutorial.html as does OData. Lucene/Solr aren't exactly what I'm looking for and are too complex for my scenario. However, they have a well defined url api.

I'm looking for any other well define url-based api examples. I want to see the "prior art" for defining a query/search syntax based on a url and query string parameters.

like image 203
Chris Weber Avatar asked Sep 12 '11 16:09

Chris Weber


People also ask

Why is OData not popular?

The interface errs on the side of being too liberal in what it will accept. The contract does not provide enough information to consumers on how to use the service. If a consumer must read something other than the service's signature to understand how to use the service, the factoring of the service should be reviewed.

Is GraphQL same as OData?

1. OData is basically a standard that defines the best practices for the user for building and consuming the restAPIs. GraphQL is like a programming language, a query language that is used to fulfill those queries with the complete understanding of data in your API.

Is OData any good?

An OData API is a good fit when you know that consumers of your API will come from a broad group of developers of different technologies, often with an enterprise slant. OData is a simpler concept and has a simpler definition for queries than GraphQL, which are powerful enough to meet most use cases.

What is the difference between OData and REST API?

REST stands for REpresentational State Transfer which is a resource based architectural style. Resource based means that data and functionalities are considered as resources. OData is a web based protocol that defines a set of best practices for building and consuming RESTful web services.


1 Answers

While some will certainly argue, rolling your own is certainly an option; provided you can release a consumable schema and syntax or API library. Given that you carefully research the current standards landscape and borrow from established (albeit unfitting) implementations, you (and supporters) could be inclined to produce a new or extended standard; perhaps one that solves an unsolved problem.

However, obligatory:
xkcd #927

like image 129
Dan Lugg Avatar answered Oct 09 '22 11:10

Dan Lugg