Android: Auto-reconnect BLE devices

Question

My goal is to get the Android device to reconnect to a BLE device that it has previously connected to without user intervention in the same way it does for a classic BT paired device does (even works through power cycles).

One of the ideas of BTLE devices is that one saves service, bonding, and enabling states such that a reconnect is VERY fast and consumes very little power on the peripheral.

What I have done seems to work but it works poorly.

The first step is to connect or pair and connect to a new device setting the 'autoconnect' parameter to 'true'. When the device disconnects, do not call gatt.close(). Everywhere I look I see that one should call gatt.close(). But if I do call gatt.close() the Android central app never reconnects. I have tested this many times.

If I have not called gatt.close() and have not power cycled the Android, the auto-connection usually happens. Sometimes it can take a long time, especially after version 5.0. It is, however, unreliable and it may be unreliable due to a very low-duty scan cycle and the device quitting advertising before a scan cycle actually detects the advertisement. I am not sure because there is no way to detect the scanning operation like there is advertisements! It is also possible the scanning stops after a certain amount of time but there is no documentation on that.

So what I think I need to do is to somehow set the background scan rate used by the Android to a higher duty cycle (only possible in 5.0 and up) when auto-connect has been set but I do not know how to do this. I do not want to start my own scan but somehow set the background scanning rate used by Android for the reconnect. Does anyone know how to do this? Does anyone really know how autoconnect and gatt.close() are to work?

Maybe the auto-connect was NOT meant to re-connect as I indicated above?

Answer 1

Well after many trials and tribulations this is how I best get the Android to auto connect with the only user action being to first select the device (if using the settings menu then first pairing).

You have to trap the paired event in a BroadcastReceiver and do a BluetoothDevice.connectGatt() setting the autoconnect to true. Then when the device disconnects, invoke a gatt.connect().

Update: While the above approach works in general, it is sometimes agonizingly slow probably because the pending connection uses extremely conservative scan rates. The other downside is that for each device you want to auto-reconnect to you have to keep a BluetoothGatt object performing a pending connection. In the embedded world this is insane. Instead what one does is continuously scan and connect to a desired device by inspecting its advertisement. One saves only the minimal amount of data about the device (the services, its paired state and keys, etc.). When an advertisement is captured you see if it is one of your known devices and connect to if it is. I tried the equivalent on Android. Scan all the time (low power rate) and connect to advertisements of interest, and maintain a class representing a known device. There are some annoying details in this approach (like turning off scanning while connecting and restarting after connected) but it basically works without the overhead of maintaining connections. BUT there is one exception I do not understand. One pre-paired device's advertisements are never seen by the scanner. However, if I invoke a pending connection to this device, I re-connect. I do not understand this at all. On my embedded platforms it works as it should. If anyone else has tried this approach for auto-reconnecting, please share your experiences!

I have discovered the reason the pre-paired device is not seen by Android. Android only reports scan results IF the device responds to a scan request. Once paired, this device only emits advertisements and ignores scan requests, so the Android system does not pass up its advertisements in the ScanCallback. Thus in order to work using the scan approach, I have to use the pending connect approach for those specific devices. It just seems like you can't win!

============= UPDATE 2020

Many years have passed and I have a lot more experience with the background scan approach. If one keeps the supported platforms 5 and up, one can use only the newest scanner APIs and use filters, eliminating the need to decode the raw advertisements yourself. I have also found that connection and re-connection is snappier if you DONT turn off scanning while connecting. I know it goes against all documentation, but it works and on some platforms allowed connections to happen that otherwise did not. Also, to date, I have found only one (health) device that needs pending connects. Disclaimer: All I have ever worked with is health devices.