Adler32 Repeating Very Quickly

Question

I'm using the adler32 checksum algorithm to generate a number from a database id. So, when I insert a row into the database, I take the identity of that row and use it to create the checksum. The problem that I'm running into is that I just generated a repeat checksum after only 207 inserts into the database. This is much much faster than I expected. Here is my code:

String dbIdStr = Long.toString(dbId);
byte[] bytes = dbIdStr.getBytes();
Checksum checksum = new Adler32();
checksum.update(bytes, 0, bytes.length);
result = checksum.getValue();

Is there something wrong with what/how I'm doing? Should I be using a different method to create unique strings? I'm doing this because I don't want to use the db id in a url... a change to the structure of the db will break all the links out there in the world.

Thanks!

Answer 1

You should not be using Adler-32 as a hash code generator. That's not what it's for. You should use an algorithm that has good hash properties, which, among other things minimizes the probability of collisions.

You can simply use Java's hashCode method (on any object). For the String object, the hash code is the sum of the byte values of string times successive powers of 31. There can be collisions with very short strings, but it's not a horrible algorithm. It's definitely a lot better than Adler-32 as a hash algorithm.

The suggestions to use a cryptographically secure hash function (like SHA-256) are certainly overkill for your application, both in terms of execution time and hash code size. You should try Java's hashCode and see how many collisions you get. If it seems much more frequent than you'd expect for a 2^-n probability (where n is the number of bits in the hash code), then you can override it with a better one. You can find a link here for decent Java hash functions.