Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Why does scipy bessel root finding not return roots at zero?

I am trying to use code which uses Bessel function zeros for other calculations. I noticed the following piece of code produces results that I consider unexpected.

    import scipy
    from scipy import special

    scipy.special.jn_zeros(1,2)

I would expect the result from this call to be

    array([0., 3.83170597])

instead of

    array([3.83170597, 7.01558667])

Is there a reason a reason why the root at x=0.0 is not being returned?

From what I can see the roots are symmetric along the x-axis except for any found at the origin, but I do not think this would be enough of a reason to leave off the root completely.

The computer I am using has python version 2.7.10 installed and is using scipy version 0.19.0

P.S. the following function is what I am trying to find the zeros of

    scipy.special.j1
like image 673
WolcottR Avatar asked Feb 17 '26 04:02

WolcottR


1 Answers

It appears to be convention to not count the zero at zero, see for example ħere. Maybe it is considered redundant?

like image 81
Paul Panzer Avatar answered Feb 19 '26 17:02

Paul Panzer



Donate For Us

If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!