JXA: Accessing CFString constants from CoreServices

Question

JXA, with its built-in ObjC bridge, exposes enumeration and constants from the Foundation framework automatically via the $ object; e.g.:

$.NSUTF8StringEncoding  // -> 4

However, there are also useful CFString constants in lower-level APIs that aren't automatically imported, namely the kUTType* constants in CoreServices that define frequently-used UTI values, such as kUTTypeHTML for UTI "public.html".

While you can import them with ObjC.import('CoreServices'), their string value isn't (readily) accessible, presumably because its type is CFString[Ref]:

ObjC.import('CoreServices') // import kUTType* constants; ObjC.import('Cocoa') works too
$.kUTTypeHTML  // returns an [object Ref] instance - how do you get its string value?

I have yet to find a way to get at the string at the heart of what's returned: ObjC.unwrap($.kUTTypeHTML) doesn't work, and neither does ObjC.unwrap($.kUTTypeHTML[0]) (nor .deepUnwrap()).

I wonder:

• if there's a native JXA way to do this that I'm missing.
• otherwise, if there's away to use ObjC.bindFunction() to define bindings for CFString*() functions that can solve the problem, such as to CFStringGetCString() or CFStringGetCStringPtr(), but it's not obvious to me how to translate the ObjC signatures.

Answer 1

While I don't understand all implications, the following seems to work:

$.CFStringGetCStringPtr($.kUTTypeHTML, 0) // -> 'public.html'

# Alternative, with explicit UTF-8 encoding specification
$.CFStringGetCStringPtr($.kUTTypeHTML, $.kCFStringEncodingUTF8) // ditto

The kUTType* constants are defined as CFStringRef, and CFStringGetCStringPtr returns a CFString object's internal C string in the specified encoding, if it can be extracted "with no memory allocations and no copying, in constant time" - or NULL otherwise.

With the built-in constants, it seems that a C string (rather than NULL) is always returned, which - by virtue of C data types mapping onto JXA data types - is directly usable in JavaScript:

 $.CFStringGetCStringPtr($.kUTTypeHTML, 0) === 'public.html' // true

For background information (as of OSX 10.11.1), read on.

---

JXA doesn't natively recognize CFString objects, even though they can be "toll-free bridged" to NSString, a type that JXA does recognize.

You can verify that JXA does not know the equivalence of CFString and NSString by executing $.NSString.stringWithString($.kUTTypeHTML).js, which should return a copy of the input string, but instead fails with -[__NSDictionaryM length]: unrecognized selector sent to instance.

Not recognizing CFString is our starting point: $.kUTTypeHTML is of type CFString[Ref], but JXA doesn't return a JS string representation of it, only [object Ref].

^{Note: The following is in part speculative - do tell me if I'm wrong.}

Not recognizing CFString has another side effect, namely when invoking CF*() functions that accept a generic type (or Cocoa methods that accept a toll-free bridged CF* type that JXA is unaware of):
In such cases, if the argument type doesn't exactly match the invoked function's parameter type, JXA apparently implicitly wraps the input object in a CFDictionary instance, whose only entry has key type, with the associated value containing the original object.^[1]

Presumably, this is why the above $.NSString.stringWithString() call fails: it is being passed the CFDictionary wrapper rather than the CFString instance.

Another case in point is the CFGetTypeID() function, which expects a CFTypeRef argument: i.e., any CF* type.

Since JXA doesn't know that it's OK to pass a CFStringRef argument as-is as the CFTypeRef parameter, it mistakenly performs the above-mentioned wrapping, and effectively passes a CFDictionary instance instead:

$.CFGetTypeID($.kUTTypeHTML) // -> !! 18 (CFDictionary), NOT 7 (CFString)

This is what houthakker experienced in his solution attempt.

For a given CF* function you can bypass the default behavior by using ObjC.bindFunction() to redefine the function of interest:

// Redefine CFGetTypeID() to accept any type as-is:
ObjC.bindFunction('CFGetTypeID', ['unsigned long', [ 'void *']])

Now, $.CFGetTypeID($.kUTTypeHTML) correctly returns 7 (CFString).

^{Note: The redefined $.CFGetTypeID() returns a JS Number instance, whereas the original returns a string representation of the underlying number (CFTypeID value).}

Generally, if you want to know the specific type of a given CF* instance informally, use CFShow(), e.g.:

$.CFShow($.kUTTypeHTML) // -> '{\n    type = "{__CFString=}";\n}'

^{Note: CFShow() returns nothing and instead prints directly to stderr, so you can't capture the output in JS.
You may redefine CFShow with ObjC.bindFunction('CFShow', ['void', [ 'void *' ]]) so as not to show the wrapper dictionary.}

For natively recognized CF* types - those that map onto JS primitives - you'll see the specific type directly (e.g., CFBoolean for false); for unknown - and therefore wrapped - instances, you'll see the wrapper structure as above - read on for more.

---

^[1] Running the following gives you an idea of the wrapper object being generated by JXA when passing an unknown type:

// Note: CFShow() prints a description of the type of its argument
//  directly to stderr.
$.CFShow($.kUTTypeHTML) // -> '{\n    type = "{__CFString=}";\n}'

// Alternative that *returns* the description as a JS string:
$.CFStringGetCStringPtr($.CFCopyDescription($.kUTTypeHTML), 0) // -> (see above)

Similarly, using the known-to-JXA equivalence of NSDictionary and CFDictionary,

ObjC.deepUnwrap($.NSDictionary.dictionaryWithDictionary( $.kUTTypeHTML ))

returns {"type":"{__CFString=}"}, i.e., a JS object with property type whose value is at this point - after an ObjC-bridge call roundtrip - a mere string representation of what presumably was the original CFString instance.

---

houthakker's solution attempt also contains a handy snippet of code to obtain the type name of a CF* instance as a string.

If we refactor it into a function and apply the necessary redefinition of CFGetTypeID(), we get the following, HOWEVER:

• A hack is needed to make it return a value predictably (see comments and source code)
• Even then a random character sometimes appears as the end of the string returned, such as CFString, rather than CFString.

^{If anyone has an explanation for why the hack is needed and where the random characters come from, please let me know. The issues may be memory-management related, as both CFCopyTypeIDDescription() and CFStringCreateExternalRepresentation() return an object that the caller must release, and I don't know whether/how/when JXA does that.}

/* 
  Returns the type name of the specified CF* (CoreFoundation) type instance.
  CAVEAT:
   * A HACK IS EMPLOYED to ensure that a value is consistently returned f
     those CF* types that correspond to JS primitives, such as CFNumber, 
     CFBoolean, and CFString:
     THE CODE IS CALLED IN A TIGHT LOOP UNTIL A STRING IS RETURNED.
     THIS SEEMS TO WORK WELL IN PRACTICE, BUT CAVEAT EMPTOR.
     Also, ON OCCASION A RANDOM CHARACTER APPEARS AT THE END OF THE STRING.
   * Only pass in true CF* instances, as obtained from CF*() function
     calls or constants such as $.kUTTypeHTML. Any other type will CRASH the
     function. 

  Example:
    getCFTypeName($.kUTTypeHTML) // -> 'CFString'  
*/
function getCFTypeName(cfObj) {

  // Redefine CFGetTypeID() so that it accepts unkown types as-is
  // Caution:
  //  * ObjC.bindFunction() always takes effect *globally*.
  //  * Be sure to pass only true CF* instances from then on, otherwise
  //    the function will crash.
  ObjC.bindFunction('CFGetTypeID', [ 'unsigned long', [ 'void *' ]])

  // Note: Ideally, we'd redefine CFCopyDescription() analogously and pass 
  // the object *directly* to get a description, but this is not an option:
  //   ObjC.bindFunction('CFCopyDescription', ['void *', [ 'void *' ]])
  // doesn't work, because, since we're limited to *C* types,  we can't describe
  // the *return* type in a way that CFStringGetCStringPtr() - which expects
  // a CFStringRef - would then recognize ('Ref has incompatible type').

  // Thus, we must first get a type's numerical ID with CFGetTypeID() and then
  // get that *type*'s description with CFCopyTypeIDDescription().
  // Unfortunately, passing the resulting CFString to $.CFStringGetCStringPtr()
  // does NOT work: it yields NULL - no idea why.
  // 
  // Using $.CFStringCreateExternalRepresentation(), which yields a CFData
  // instance, from which a C string pointer can be extracted from with 
  // CFDataGetBytePtr(), works:
  //  - reliably with non-primitive types such as CFDictionary
  //  - only INTERMITTENTLY with the equivalent types of JS primitive types
  //    (such as CFBoolean, CFString, and CFNumber) - why??
  //    Frequently, and unpredictably, `undefined` is returned.
  // !! THUS, THE FOLLOWING HACK IS EMPLOYED: THE CODE IS CALLED IN A TIGHT
  // !! LOOP UNTIL A STRING IS RETURNED. THIS SEEMS TO WORK WELL IN PRACTICE,
  // !! BUT CAVEAT EMPTOR.
  //    Also, sometimes, WHEN A STRING IS RETURNED, IT MAY CONTAIN A RANDOM
  //    EXTRA CHAR. AT THE END.
  do {
    var data = $.CFStringCreateExternalRepresentation(
            null, // use default allocator
            $.CFCopyTypeIDDescription($.CFGetTypeID(cfObj)), 
            0x08000100, // kCFStringEncodingUTF8
            0 // loss byte: n/a here
        ); // returns a CFData instance
    s = $.CFDataGetBytePtr(data)
  } while (s === undefined)
  return s
}

Answer 2

You can coerce a CF type to an NS type by first re-binding the CFMakeCollectable function so that it takes 'void *' and returns 'id', and then using that function to perform the coercion:

ObjC.bindFunction('CFMakeCollectable', [ 'id', [ 'void *' ] ]);

var cfString = $.CFStringCreateWithCString(0, "foo", 0); // => [object Ref]
var nsString = $.CFMakeCollectable(cfString);            // => $("foo")

To make this easier to use in your code, you might define a .toNS() function on the Ref prototype:

Ref.prototype.toNS = function () { return $.CFMakeCollectable(this); }

Here is how you would use this new function with a CFString constant:

ObjC.import('CoreServices')

$.kUTTypeHTML.toNS() // => $("public.html")